Decide the argument before the layout
Redesigns fail when they begin in a design tool. The first artefact should be the argument: who this page is for, what they currently believe, what they need to believe to act, and in what order that case must be made. Once the argument exists, layout becomes a series of straightforward decisions, because every section has a job. Without it, design becomes taste negotiation and the finished site looks contemporary while saying nothing specific. This is also why the most effective website projects spend their first two weeks on messaging and evidence rather than on visual direction. When the argument is right, even modest design executes well. When it is wrong, exceptional design simply makes the confusion beautiful.